Overflow noise - not any more!
I installed the ‘Herbie Overflow’ method on my system and it works like a charm.
(Click image to enlarge)
My installation may not be a ‘standard’ Herbie, but it works very well for me.
Main Return - If the valve is left fully open the syphon effect will empty the weir too quickly, the water over the weir will splash and gurgle (lots of noise!). Slowly close down the valve until the water rises in the weir and just ‘trickles’ down the Balanced Return pipe. It takes a little time to balance.
Once done - No trickle noise from the weir and no gurgling - Silence!
Do not use strainers on either of the Weir pipes. From experience - they always clog! I capture detritus at the sump end, using coarse foam and filter floss. (A filter sock would work just as well.)
Do put unions on either side of the valve so you can take it out for annual cleaning.
Balance Return – This is left just above the Sump water level so you can see the amount of flow (trickle) as you adjust the valve. Once set. I add a short length of pipe to extend this to just below the water level, stopping any trickle noise at the sump end. The curve at the top, stops any noise from the trickle of water at the tank end.
Valve – Best option is Spears Gate Valve, as it enables finer balancing. A True Union Ball Valve could also be used, but not the cheaper strait ball valves.
Fit the valve as near to the end of the return pipe as possible, and easily accessible.
Pumps & Piping - I run two Jacod DCP 8000 DC feed pumps, each one moving c.6000 litres per hour (c.1,580 UK gph).
Two 25mm UPVC pipes, feed the display tank. One 40mm UPVC Main Return pipe, One 40mm Balance Return pipe & One 40mm Gate Valve. With a 6.5 meter horizontal run between the Display Tank and the Sump.
Weir - I use high capacity weir comb (not essential for silent operation) and have a glass cover over the weir to stop fish & critters entering. example
Do make absolutely sure you have sufficient capacity in your sump for when the pump is turned off, as the the water from the weir and the top of the display tank, flows back to the sump. Do use a cover over the weir box to stop critters entering and being 'wizzed' to the sump. Do not add 'one way' valves to the system. In my experience, they constrict water flow and regularly fail!
System originally nstalled 2016. No issues experienced at all. Annual maintenance only.
A good article for more information can be found at:
The two right angled joints that form the top of the Main Return and the top of the Balanced Return are ‘push fit’ ( i.e. not glued). This allows easy access for inspection/cleaning.
Weir / Top of Balanced Return showing the 5mm air hole.